13 Best Cruelty-Free Eyeliners with Clean Formulas in 2024

We understand the importance of both compassionate and conscious beauty. That’s why we’ve handpicked 13 best cruelty-free eyeliners with clean formulas, that not only deliver stunning results but also adhere to cruelty-free standards and embrace clean formulas. 

Say goodbye to the dilemma of choosing between high-performance makeup and your values. Our comprehensive guide takes the guesswork out of your search, presenting you with a collection of top-notch eyeliners that will transform your eye looks without compromising on ethics or quality.

More about Cruelty-Free Skincare: Best Cruelty-Free Vitamin C Serums, Best Cruelty-Free Hyaluronic Acid Serums, Best Cruelty-Free Face Washes.

The Conscious Insider is reader supported. When you buy something we recommend, we might earn an affiliate commission at no extra charge for you.

Why Choose Cruelty-Free Eyeliners?

Choosing cruelty-free skincare is a conscious decision that speaks about your values and compassion. It’s about making a stand for the rights and well-being of animals, while still pampering yourself with effective products.

When you choose cruelty-free skincare, you actively contribute to ending the needless suffering of animals. You become part of a movement that believes in finding alternative, humane methods for testing and developing products. By supporting brands that prioritize animal welfare, you send a powerful message to the industry, urging them to embrace compassion and embrace change.

Beyond the ethical considerations, cruelty-free skincare also offers other benefits for your own well-being. These products are often crafted with natural and organic ingredients. Free from harmful chemicals and toxins, cruelty-free skincare helps you achieve a radiant complexion safely.

Many cruelty-free skincare brands go the extra mile to embrace sustainability. They make mindful choices, from eco-friendly packaging to sourcing ingredients responsibly that participate to the preservation of our planet.

Ultimately, opting for cruelty-free skincare is about empowerment. It’s about taking control of your choices and investing in products that align with your values. By doing so, you inspire others to follow suit, creating a ripple effect of change in the beauty industry.

How do you check if a brand is cruelty-free?

Look for the Leaping Bunny or PETA certifications.

Leaping Bunny certifies cruelty-free companies for almost 30 years.
Those companies have pledged to end animal testing at all stages of product development. They need to recommit every year and accept to be audited by third parties. Currently, about 2400 companies are certified by Leaping Bunny. Companies selling products in China can not be cruelty-free certified. Animal testing is mandatory to enter the Chinese market.
The Leaping Bunny seal is one of the most sought-after clean beauty certification. 

Peta’s cruelty-free label also certifies cruelty-free companies since 1984.  
It ensures that brands and their suppliers do not conduct, commission, pay for, or allow any tests on animals for their ingredients, formulations, or finished products anywhere in the world and that they will never do so in the future.
This clean beauty certification is highly popular among consumers who care for animal welfare.

Best Overall Cruelty-Free Eyeliner

gluten-free eyeliners
gluten-free eyeliners

1. 100% Pure – Long Last Liquid Eye Liner

Review | 4.3/5 stars over 1,309 reviews

Features | Natural, Vegan & Cruelty-free, made in the USA, Gluten-free

Price | $30

Customer Review | This Eye Liner is by far the Best Eye Liner I’ve ever used. It goes on smooth and lasts all day without fail. It washes off with soap and water. My most favorite part is that it has all healthy ingredients.” Janet

  • Liquid liner richly pigmented
  • Long-lasting, smudge-proof, and water-resistant
  • 3 shades available

Shop on Amazon

Shop on Brand Website

Best Cruelty-Free Eyeliner For Clean & Organic Ingredients

gluten-free eyeliners
gluten-free eyeliners

2. Juice Beauty – Phyto-Pigments Precision Eye Pencil

Review | 4.2/5 stars over 59 reviews

Features | Organic Ingredients, Vegan, Cruelty-free, Gluten-free, Silicone-free

Price | $20

Customer Review |I love that this pencil goes on soft and easy. It gives a Smokey look without having to do extra smudging.” Erin

  • Antioxidant-rich formula
  • From subtle yet precise, to bold & dramatic definition
  • 2 shades available

Shop on Brand Website

Best Cruelty-Free Eyeliner With Affordable Price

gluten-free eyeliners
gluten-free eyeliners

3. Pacifica – Vegan Longwear Eyeliner

Review | 4.8/5 stars over 55 reviews

Features | Gluten-free, vegan and cruelty-free. Free from talc, parabens, phthalates or mineral oil

Price | $11

Customer Review | Super fun colors, I purchased the mint. Love it! Easy to apply. Bright color that did not budge until I removed my make up! I’ll be back to purchase more colors.” Spacedust

  • Easy-glide formula to create clean and precise lines
  • Pigmented plant-powered eyeliner with a longwearing formula
  • 4 shades available

Shop on Amazon

Shop on Brand Website

Best Cruelty-Free Eyeliners For Sensitive Eyes

4. Honest Beauty – Liquid Eyeliner 

Review | 4.1/5 stars over 3,561 reviews

Features | Cruelty-free, Vegan, Non-Toxic EWG Certified, Free from Parabens, Carbon Black Pigment, Silicones, PEGs, Dermatologist and Ophthalmologist Tested, Hypoallergenic

Price | $14.99

Customer Review | This liquid eyeliner goes on smoothly and lasts from am – pm! I have recommend it to my friends.” AJ

  • Fine line to dramatic & bold thick wings with satin finish
  • Lasts up to 8 hours 
  • No smudging or flaking

Shop on Amazon 

Shop on Brand Website

gluten-free eyeliners
gluten-free eyeliners

5. Benefit – They’re Real! Xtreme Precision Liner

Review | 4.7/5 stars over 961 reviews

Features | Vegan, cruelty-free and gluten-free. Free of silicone, mineral oil, talc, fragrance, parabens, sulfates, and phthalates, dermatologically tested, safe for sensitive skin, non-acnegenic, hypoallergenic

Price | $24

Customer Review | This is my new favorite eyeliner. Not inky is the brush extremely thin but also sturdy. This liner is very black in color. It doesn’t clump up and dried very fast! I’m super excited to add this into my routine!.” Tessiebu

  • Draws thin and thick lines 
  • Waterproof, Smudge-proof, Flake-free liner with a satin finish
  • 2 shades available

Shop on Brand Website

Best Cruelty-Free Gel Eyeliner 

gluten-free eyeliners
gluten-free eyeliners

6. Ilia – Clean Line Gel Liner

Review | 4.5/5 stars over 860 reviews

Features | Cruelty-Free, vegan, free from gluten, silicone and fragrance, Non-comedogenic, safe for sensitive skin, and dermatologist-tested.

Price | $26

Customer Review | This liner is so pigmented and glides smoothly. Stays on literally from 9am to 11pm— intact! Bought it in black as well. I found my new go to eye liner!” Melody

  • Soft tip gel eyeliner blending effortlessly
  • Water resistant and precise
  • 2 shades available

Shop on Amazon 

Shop on Brand Website

Best Cruelty-Free Eyeliner For Waterproof

gluten-free eyeliners
gluten-free eyeliners

7. Tarte – Quick stick waterproof shadow & liner

Review | 4.5/5 stars over 189 reviews

Features | Vegan & cruelty-free, dermatologist tested. Free from Parabens, Mineral Oil, Phthalates, Triclosan, Sodium Lauryl Sulfate, and Gluten

Price | $26

Customer Review | I have tried tons & tons of eyeshadow sticks. This is hands down the best. It goes on smoothly, lasts forever & is quick and easy.Kristen

  • Gel liner with rich, buildable color
  • Waterproof formula with no crease, transfer or smudge
  • 8 shades available

Shop on Amazon

Shop on Brand Website

Best Cruelty-Free Eyeliner For Splurge

gluten-free eyeliners
gluten-free eyeliners

8. Hourglass – Voyeur Waterproof Gel Eyeliner 

Review | 4.5/5 stars over 48 reviews

Features | Vegan friendly, Cruelty-free, Gluten-free

Price | $28

Customer Review | I recently bought this eyeliner and I have to say it is the best I have ever had and I intend to buy more colors. It is easy to apply and with the eye lid primer, it sits of the eye for hours on end. And the best thing is that it is still easy to remove. An excellent product.“ Thora

  • A waterproof gel eyeliner 
  • 12-hour wear without smudging, bleeding, or fading
  • 5 shades available 

Shop on Amazon 

Shop on Brand Website

Best Cruelty-Free Eyeliners For Longwear

gluten-free eyeliners
gluten-free eyeliners

9. Fenty Beauty – Flypencil Longwear

Review | 4.4/5 stars over 1,138 reviews

Features | Cruelty-free & Gluten-free, non comedogenic

Price | $23

Customer Review | Liked it but it could be creamier, this is a perfect eye pencil if you don’t want that immediate bold colour right away, you can build up the colour and that is why i lke it, it’s not a strong deep black right away, it starts as a grey and goes deeper and deeper.” Diogo

  • Creamy longwear pencil eyeliner
  • Water resistant
  • 20 shades available

Shop on Amazon 

Shop on Brand Website

Cruelty-Free Eyeliner

10. Elf Cosmetics – No Budge Retractable Eyeliner

Review | 4.5/5 stars over 11,770 reviews

Features | Cruelty-free, vegan, free from phthalates, parabens, nonylphenol ethoxylates, triclosan, triclocarban, and hydroquinone. Made in Fair Trade factory

Price | $5

Customer Review | This is a rare eyeliner where my eyes don’t water or get irritated from it. It is the first time trying this product and I will be getting it again.” Julie D 

  • Smudge-resistant, long-lasting formula
  • Intense color with a matte finish
  • 3 shades available

Shop on Amazon

Shop on Brand Website

Best Cruelty-Free Eyeliner For Clean Formula

gluten-free eyeliners
gluten-free eyeliners

11. Milk Makeup – Infinity Long Wear Eyeliner

Review | 4.5/5 stars over 101  reviews

Features | Vegan, clean, cruelty-free, non comedogenic, paraben-free, silicone-free, and gluten-free

Price | $22

Customer Review | This goes on super smooth and stays! Great for more subtle thin lines.” Sarah

  • Waterproof eyeliner pencil 
  • Long lasting up to 12 hours
  • 3 shades available

Shop on Amazon 

Shop on Brand Website

Best Liquid Cruelty-Free Eyeliner

gluten-free eyeliners
gluten-free eyeliners

12. EPILYNX by Dr. Liia Long Lasting Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

Review | 4.1/5 stars over 1,016  reviews

Features | Gluten-free, allergen-free, cruelty-free, nut oil-free, paraben-free, vegan, and casein-free

Price | $11.99

Customer Review | I especially like the applicator of this eyeliner, which has more of a brush feeling. The eyeliner goes on smoothly and stays on until you wash it off. The color is beautiful too, very rich and deep.” Elizabeth

  • Liquid eyeliner with precise application
  • Waterproof and smudge-proof for long-lasting wear
  • 12 shades available

Shop on Amazon 

Best Pencil Cruelty-Free  Eyeliner

gluten-free eyeliners
gluten-free eyeliners

13. Honeybee Gardens Effortless Black Matte Eye Liner Pencil

Review | 4.3/5 stars over 916  reviews

Features | Vegan, cruelty-free, gluten-free, paraben-free

Price | $9.99

Customer Review | Love all natural, non toxic items. This pencil liner goes on great!” Chloe

  • Made from those with sensitivities or allergies
  • Smooth yet long wearing with deep pigmentation
  • 6 shades available

Shop on Amazon 

All photos credits belong to respective brands

Share this post